| Name | Year of Induction |
| Larry Conley | 1977 |
| Howie Crittenden | 1977 |
| Jimmy Dan Connor | 1978 |
| Darrell Carrier | 1978 |
| Wesley Cox | 1979 |
| Warren Cooper | 1979 |
| Frank Selvy | 1980 |
| Charles Baker | 1980 |
| Darrell Griffith | 1981 |
| Jack Givens | 1982 |
| N/A | 1983 |
| N/A | 1984 |
| Dicky Beal | 1985 |
| Phil Cox | 1986 |
| Dwayne Casey | 1987 |
| Winston Bennett | 1988 |
| Jeff Hall | 1989 |
| Herbert Cook | 1990 |
| Letcher Norton | 1990 |
| Rex Chapman | 1991 |
| Jeff Jones | 1992 |
| John Pelphrey | 1993 |
| John Tong | 1993 |
| Richie Farmer | 1994 |
| Bob White | 1994 |
| N/A | 1995 |
| Travis Ford | 1996 |
| Jermaine Brown | 1997 |
| Dejuan Wheat | 1998 |
| Dwayne Morton | 1999 |
| Brian Kiser | 2000 |
| Will Carlton | 2001 |
| Derek Anderson | 2002 |
| Greg Bucker | 2003 |
| J.R. Vanhoose | 2004 |
| Kelly Wells | 2005 |
| Ralph Richardson & Harry Todd | 2006 |
| Jim McDaniels | 2007 |
| Felton Spencer | 2008 |
| Phillip Bond | 2009 |
| Scott Padgett | 2010 |
| Stan Hardin | 2011 |
| N/A | 2012 |
| Ervin Stepp | 2013 |
| Robert Washington | 2014 |
| Mike Redd | 2015 |
| Mike Fields | 2016 |
| Julian Tackett | 2017 |
| Gene Rhodes | 2018 |
| Coach Ed Diddle | 2019 |
| Billy Reed | 2020 |
| George Fant | 2021 |
| Lion David Satterly | 2022 |
| Darius Miller | 2023 |
| Derek Smith | 2024 |
| Curtis Turley | 2025 |
| Darrin Horn | 2026 |