| Name | High School | Year | College |
| Morgan Rich | Allen County – Scottsville | 2015 | University of Kentucky / University of Oklahoma |
| Emma Young | East Jessamine | 2016 | Texas A&M at Corpus Christi |
| Jordan Brock | Harlan | 2017 | Tennessee Tech |
| Ciaja Harbison | Louisville Male | 2018 | St. Louis University |
| Maaliya Owens | Scott County | 2019 | Tennessee Tech |
| Maddie Scherr | Ryle | 2020 | University of Oregon |
| Sofia Allen | Scott High School | 2021 | University of Tampa |
| Jaya McClure | Christian Academy of Louisville | 2022 | Ohio University |